My four favorite P2P lending and real-estate crowdfunding companies

Alternative investments already features a long guide comparing many peer-to-peer lending and real-estate crowdfunding companies. However, it’s a long read, and I understand it can be intimidating. So, here’s a much shorter list of my favorite companies.

Keep in mind that limiting the number of entries is necessarily unfair, and doesn’t mean that the missing ones aren’t worth investing in ! For example, Robo.cash is missing from this list, although it’s a company I strongly appreciate. So, don’t hesitate to check the longer comparison at a later date, or browse all available reviews. Diversification will allow you to reduce risk !

Peer-to-peer lending companies

Omaraha

Omaraha is still the largest part of my portfolio. In spite of a large cash drag, it’s still possible to invest in quality loans offering around 20% interest rate, for a long-term duration. However, be warned that Omaraha is probably not for beginners. Their website is dated and hard to use, and the loans are only partially guaranteed.

Grupeer

I may not be objective about Grupeer, but it’s probably my favorite P2P lending company. I’m honestly puzzled why there are not more people investing through this company. They offer guaranteed loans with an interest rate of 14% or more for a duration below one year. As time goes by, Grupeer features more and more originators with an increasing loans volume. The website is easy to use and require very little time; the only drawback I see is the lack of a secondary market. As a result, you can’t resell your loan if you find yourself in need of the money.

Mintos

Mintos‘s offering is truly impressive. There are both business and personal loans, a huge array of originators from many countries, and it offers loans both with or without buyback. In spite of this very rich offering, the website is very easy to use. It’s the perfect offer for beginners; longer-term guaranteed loans currently offer 14% interest rate.

Real-estate crowdfunding

Real-estate crowdfunding offers a great way to invest in real-estate with as little as €100. The returns are usually rather high – I actually cry when I compare them to the returns I get from a traditional real-estate investment I made several years ago -. One word of caution, though :  these returns come an equivalent level of risk. Please make sure you understand the risks associated with real-estate investments before committing your money !

CrowdEstate

CrowdEstate is by far the undisputed leader in this category. They regularly add new projects, which offer great expected returns. The investments are extremely detailed, and investors have the opportunity to ask questions before the start of the investment period. It’s a perfect way to diversify your portfolio if you already invested in the above companies !

 

 

P2P lending portfolio review for February 2018

Overview of the month

The most important change in my P2P lending portfolio was that I withdrew some cash from Omaraha. Also, in order to write Crowdestor‘s review, I invested a small sum in this firm’s first project.

Current performance

Omaraha

In spite of offering a large bonus, I got nearly no new loan at Omaraha until the very end of February. This situation has been lasting since the beginning of the year, so I decided to withdraw most of the idle funds in order to allocate them to Grupeer, Finbee and Crowdestor (in decreasing order).

My XIRR is absolutely stable compared to last month, at 20.84% versus 20.86%; it’s once again my best portfolio, and it pained me to have to withdraw money from it !

Bondora

Ah, Bondora… Once again it was a very deceiving month for this platform. I made more money with my Grupeer portfolio, although it’s twice smaller than my Bondora portfolio. Another striking figure is the received interests, which have dropped by more than 50% between January and February !

The XIRR dropped below 15%, setting a new low at 14.37% against 15.14% last month. Needless to say, that’s a very poor result, especially compared to Bondora’s “expected return” when I started investing. While this may look like a harsh judgment- after all, it’s really not a bad result by itself -, the clearly decreasing returns is really worrisome !

Grupeer

It was yet another excellent month for my portfolio at Grupeer. The XIRR  reached 14.72%, slightly above last month’s 14.63%. There were few cashback offers this month, so the returns may drop slightly; however one can only marvel at Grupeer’s very consistent returns. The reallocation from Omaraha meant that my Grupeer portfolio increased by around 10%.

Mintos

Another very stable month for this platform; the XIRR was 12.69%, compared to 12.63% last month. As a reminder, don’t forget to sign up for the cashback campaigns at they run regularly, and they offer a quick way to improve the returns of your portfolio.

Swaper

The XIRR is also very similar to January’s, at 11.90% for this month versus 11.83% for February.

Robo.cash

The XIRR increased once again, reaching 11.97%. Robo.cash is slowly recovering from the long cash drag that plagued it several months ago.

Other companies

As usual, I didn’t compute the XIRR for several companies. For Finbee and Monestro, it’s because I need to update or write the review. For CrowdEstate, BulkEstate and the very new Crowdestor, the reason is simply that I need to wait until the projects complete. I could actually provide a XIRR for CrowdEstate as one of the projects I invested in yields monthly interests, but it’s not typical from this platform’s investments.

Aggregate portfolio XIRR

That’s a value I’m really interested in; it shows the effect of the various portfolios size. It’s compute this value by simply taking the average of the XIRR for each company, weighted by its amount. This month it’s slightly down at 17.72%, versus 17.95% last month. I’m still very pleased by this result !

XIRR evolution

Earlier values until October (included) were provided by the platform or crudely estimated; from November onwards they were computed using the method outlined in this article.

Apart from Bondora’s continual downtrend, the results for most platforms are rather regular.

P2P Lending companies returns

Current allocation

I withdrew some money from Omaraha, and split this amount between Grupeer, Finbee, and a very tiny Crowdestor portfolio. This portfolio is so small compared to the other companies that there’s no legend for it ! (it’s located between CrowdEstate and Grupeer on the pie chart)

P2P lending companies allocations for February 2018

New platforms

I’ve had a portfolio for a long time at Finbee and I still have to write the review. It’s a rather complex platform with many options, and I lack time to explore it totally. But first, I  urgently need to update both Bondora and Investly reviews in order to reflect my current opinion !